What If They Didn't Owe You the Childhood You Wanted?

“Pastor, the reason I hustle the way I do is to ensure that my children don't go through what I went through in life.”
I looked at him. He seemed calm, but there was a restless storm in his eyes.
I wondered what a child could have gone through to leave such a deep, lasting impression on a grown man that it would shape how he raises his own children.
Then he continued.
“See, I was raised by my father's younger brother. I had to go live with them when I was twelve years old. My father had died, leaving my mum with six children, and I was the oldest.”
He smiled in reflection, and his eyes seemed miles away.
“I wasn't maltreated, nor was I abused. Nothing like that happened, but I also wasn't treated like I was a child in that family."
He shook his head sadly.
“My uncle always referred to me as his son, and in many ways, he treated me well. But there was still a clear difference between how I was raised and how his own children were raised.”
Then he said something that stayed with me.
“Well, looking at the bright side, all those years of manual labour, waking up long before dawn to clean, mop and wash my uncle's van and sometimes clothes, made me the relentless, hardworking man I am today."
“But sometimes, I wish I had been able to relax and have fun like my cousins.
“I wish I could have slept in sometimes and been chauffeur-driven to school.”
“I wish I had attended the kind of schools they attended.”
“I wish I had experienced some of the things they experienced.”
He sighed. Then came the sentence that summed up his story.
“I am doing everything I can now to make sure that even if I die young as my father did, my children will never go through what I went through.”
I understood him. But I also began to wonder:
What if the story he's carried all these years isn't the whole story?
I have heard variations of this story countless times.
A child loses a parent or is separated from their family for one reason or another and is taken in by an uncle, aunt, grandparent, sibling or another relative.
Years later, that child grows up and remembers the differences.
“My cousins had better clothes.”
“They went to better schools.”
“They didn't have to work as much.”
“They were treated like children while I was treated like a house help.”
“They had opportunities I didn't have.”
And more often than not, the pain morphs into resentment and then bitterness. And with the bitterness comes a sad and permanent verdict:
“They never really loved me.”
But have we stopped to think of how we might just be judging an entire lifetime through the eyes of a child who only saw one side of the story?
This is where I suspect many people will disagree with me, and that's okay. But let's talk.
You see, different children can grow up in the same family but, live in different worlds. I will explain.
When we examined this young man's story more closely, two things became clear.
First, there was more than a seven-year age gap between him and his uncle's first child. So, his cousins were basically preschoolers and babies when he got there. They were too young to do the type of chores he had to do.
Second, and perhaps more importantly, his uncle's financial circumstances had changed significantly by the time his own children reached the age at which this young man had entered the family.
This detail changes the whole story by a mile!
You see, we often overlook something very fundamental about family life. And this is the fact that families have seasons.
A man can have three children and raise each of them under completely different circumstances.
The first child may be born when the parents are struggling to pay rent, while the second may grow up when the family has become financially stable.
The third may arrive when the parents are doing very well financially, and the last child may grow up when the parents have retired and are living off investments and pensions.
The children all belong to the same parents and may live in the same house and carry the same surname.
They, however, are not necessarily going to have the same childhood. And that doesn't automatically mean one child was loved more than another. It's just that circumstances changed with the years.
This young man had to wake up early and do manual work because, at that time, his uncle could not afford to employ people to do those things.
By the time his cousins were old enough to take on similar responsibilities, the family's financial situation had improved.
There was money to hire labour and enough resources for better schools and amenities.
There was money for convenience! Something that simply wasn't possible before.
So, here's the question I would love answered.
“Was he treated differently because he was less loved or because he arrived in a different season?”
Yet, another important detail we often overlook is the fact that your benefactor had a life before you arrived.
When someone takes you in after tragedy strikes your family, remember that they did not plan their life around you.
They most often than not already had plans, dreams and valid financial commitments.
Remember also that they most likely had expectations for their marriage and plans for their children.
Then life happened.
A sibling died. A relative became vulnerable, or a child needed a home…
…and they opened their door.
We sometimes talk about this as though the moment someone takes a relative into their home, they automatically become morally obligated to provide that person with the same life they provide for their biological children.
But is that really fair?
Should accommodating you require them to abandon plans they had already made for their own children?
Should their own children lose opportunities because their parents decided to help you?
Should they be expected to give you everything they eventually become capable of giving their own children?
I honestly don't think so.
But before you get angry with me, let me clarify something.
I am not saying people should mistreat children they take in. I am not defending abuse, nor am I defending neglect.
I am not saying a child should be treated as inferior because they are not biologically related, but rather saying something much simpler.
I am saying: Different treatment is not automatically mistreatment, and fairness is not always equality.
We have become so obsessed with equality that we sometimes forget that fairness and equality are not always the same thing.
Imagine two children.
One is born into your family, and the other arrives because tragedy has struck theirs. You decide to take the second child in.
You feed both of them, provide shelter and protection for them and educate them. But perhaps your biological child gets certain privileges that the other child doesn't.
Does that automatically make you wicked?
Does it automatically mean you hate the other child?
Does it mean the child you took in should spend the rest of their life resenting you?
I honestly don't think the answer is that simple, because there is another question we rarely ask.
What would have happened if you had not taken that child in at all?
What if the uncle had said,“I'm sorry, I already have my own children and cannot take responsibility for another child?”
What then? Would the child have had a better childhood?
Would they have attended a better school or had better opportunities?
Sometimes we become so focused on what someone did not give us that we completely forget to ask what our lives might have looked like if they had given us nothing at all.
There is an important caveat, though.
Not every painful childhood story is a result of “different seasons.”
Some children were genuinely abused, and some were deliberately neglected. Some were exploited, treated as unpaid domestic labour while the biological children were treated like royalty. While some others were constantly reminded that they were outsiders, and denied opportunities simply because they were not biological children.
That is wrong, and we should have the courage to say so.
But there is a difference between acknowledging genuine mistreatment and assuming that every difference in treatment was intentional discrimination.
The explanation could be more complicated than that. Adults most of the time don't let children in on their challenges or struggles.
The person raising you could have been struggling or perhaps even genuinely made mistakes and it's also possible they did the best they could or perhaps could have done better.
A person's experience can be valid without their interpretation of another person's intentions being completely accurate.
You can genuinely feel that you were treated differently, and you may genuinely have been treated differently and be hurt by it.
That doesn't, however, automatically prove that the person intended to hurt you, because if we are not careful, we can spend our entire adult lives angry at people for motives they may never have had.
I believe true healing requires us to be courageous enough to ask:
“Is there another way to understand what happened?”
It is okay to acknowledge that your childhood hurt you and still be grateful for those who helped you.It is also okay to think that they could have treated you better while acknowledging that they still did more for you than they were obligated to do.
You can acknowledge that you didn't get everything you wanted and still recognise that you received something you might never have received if they had simply walked away.
These statements are not contradictions. We don't have to turn people into villains simply because they weren't perfect.
Perhaps, instead of asking:
“Why didn't they treat me like their own child?”
You should ask the more uncomfortable question like:
“Why did they take me in at all?”
"Why did they assume a responsibility that was not originally theirs?"
"Why didn't they simply walk away?"
Because as harsh as it might sound, your benefactor did not cause your tragedy. They were not responsible for whatever placed you in the vulnerable state you were in.
They did not cause the poverty your family experienced and did not necessarily owe you the life you imagined you should have had.
They stepped into a situation they did not create and tried to manage it with whatever resources they had.
It's possible they did it imperfectly, but imperfect help is still help.
There is something else worth considering. While the twelve-year-old version of you may have had every right to feel hurt, however, the adult version of you has access to information that the child did not.
The child saw the better school, unequal treatment, and a life of ease by his cousins. The adult could investigate to see if the inequality was deliberate, circumstantial or simply a consequence of changing seasons.
This is not about invalidating the child, but allowing yourself the courage to revisit your stories so that you can understand the story more completely.
This is not to erase what happened. It is not a call to pretend the pain wasn't real, or to manufacture gratitude where there was genuine cruelty. But rather, to ask whether the story we have been telling ourselves for twenty, thirty or forty years is the only possible interpretation of what happened.
So, we don't end up misinterpreting limitations as abandonment or see a lack of resources as a lack of love and care.
For what we may remember as “they didn't give me enough” may also be a story about someone who gave what they could when they didn't have to give anything at all.
So, Where Do We Draw the Line?
If someone takes in a relative's child, are they morally obligated to provide the same lifestyle they provide their biological children?
If they cannot, does that make them unfair?
If the child grows up feeling disadvantaged, should that feeling automatically become a verdict against the person who raised them?
If someone gave you a home when they could have walked away, but they did not give you the childhood you wanted, should your strongest memory of them be gratitude, resentment or some complicated combination of both?
“What does fairness really look like when life forces someone to raise a child they never planned for?”
I would love to hear your thoughts on this.

0 Comment
No comment yet. Be the first to comment!